Mark & Kleinfeldt, LLC Blog | New Jersey Lawyers

Should I Sign a Severance Agreement After Being Fired?

Written by Jamison Mark | Nov 19, 2026, 12:15:00 PM

Should I Sign a Severance Agreement After Being Fired?

Getting fired is overwhelming, and being handed a severance agreement on your way out only adds to the pressure. While a lump sum of cash might feel like a lifeline in a moment of uncertainty, it is crucial to remember one thing: these agreements are drafted by your employer's lawyers to protect their interests, not yours.

Before you put pen to paper, you need to understand what you are really giving up when you sign and how to know if you should negotiate for more.

Why Employers Offer Severance Agreements

Before diving into the specifics of the contract, we need to frame the reality of why you are being offered this package. Employers rarely offer severance purely out of generosity.

The main goal of a severance agreement is to buy a release of all your potential legal claims against the company. They want to ensure a quiet, risk-free exit and eliminate the possibility of future litigation. However, many employees do not realize that because the employer is trying to buy something from them, the initial offer is often negotiable.

Think of a severance package as a business transaction. You have something they desperately want—your signature and your silence—which gives you inherent leverage.

 

What You Are Actually Giving Up

When you sign a severance agreement, you are making substantial concessions. Here are the three main things you are typically giving up:

1. The General Release of Claims

The core of any severance agreement is the general release. By signing, you are waiving your right to sue the company for wrongful termination. You are giving up any potential discrimination or retaliation claims, and specifically preventing future lawsuits under robust New Jersey employment laws, such as the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination (NJLAD) or the Conscientious Employee Protection Act (CEPA).

2. Future Career Restrictions

Severance agreements often contain post-employment restrictive covenants. These may include non-compete clauses that strictly limit where you can work next, or non-solicitation clauses that prevent you from reaching out to former clients or poaching former colleagues. Overly broad restrictions in these documents can severely stall your career momentum.

3. Your Right to Speak Out

Employers want to control the narrative. The agreement will likely include non-disparagement clauses, meaning you agree to never criticize the company or its executives publicly. It will also mandate confidentiality surrounding the circumstances of your departure and strict restrictions on discussing the amount of the severance package itself.

 

Major Red Flags to Watch Out For

Not all severance agreements are created equal. As a New Jersey employment attorney, here are the major red flags I look for when reviewing a client's agreement:

High-pressure tactics:

Unreasonably short deadlines designed to force you into signing before you can seek counsel.

 

Interference with unemployment:

Language attempting to block your right to collect unemployment benefits.

 

Unfair restrictions:

Broad non-compete agreements without any extra compensation tied specifically to that restriction.

 

Theft of earned compensation:

Clauses that trick you into giving up already earned wages, unpaid commissions, or accrued PTO that you are legally owed regardless of the severance.

 

Vague definitions:

Ambiguous language regarding termination for "cause" or the return of "company property."

 

Insight:

The more the employer pressures you to sign immediately, the more likely it is they are hiding a legal vulnerability and fear you will discover it.

 

Do You Have Leverage to Negotiate?

How do you know if that initial offer is just a starting point? Ask yourself these key questions:

  1. Were you fired shortly after complaining about illegal activity, workplace safety, or harassment?
  2. Are you in a protected class (based on race, gender, age, disability, etc.), and were you treated differently than other employees in similar situations?
  3. Did the company violate your employment contract or fail to follow its own disciplinary policies leading up to your termination?

Key Concept: If your termination was potentially unlawful, the value of your signature is much higher than a standard, formulaic severance offer. You have leverage.

 

What to Do When Handed a Severance Agreement

If you are handed a severance package, follow these four steps to protect yourself:

Step 1 — Do Not Sign on the Spot

Severance agreements represent a major risk point for employees. Never sign the document immediately in the HR office. Take it home.

 

Step 2 — Check the Deadline

Note the deadline to accept. Be aware of federally protected review periods; for example, under the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA), employees who are 40 or older must be given at least 21 days to review a severance offer.

 

Step 3 — Secure Your Documentation

Preserve your evidence legally. Secure your performance reviews, copies of relevant emails (if you still have lawful access), and any communications regarding your termination.

 

Step 4 — Speak With an Employment Attorney Early

Consult with an experienced New Jersey employment attorney before any critical deadlines pass. We can evaluate the strength of your potential claims and tell you if the offer is fair.

 

Conclusion

A severance agreement is a legally binding contract that can profoundly impact your finances and your future employment trajectory. Signing too quickly might mean leaving money on the table—or worse, signing away your fundamental right to hold an abusive employer accountable. Before you sign your rights away, get a professional legal review.